Mr. Brett's Epitaph
Publication details
- Content type
- Interview
- Publication type
- Magazine
- Source
- The Big Takeover #36 (1994)
- Published
- September 1, 1994
- Country
- United States
- With / about
- Greg Hetson, Greg Graffin, Brett Gurewitz
- Synopsis
- The Big Takeover interviews Greg Graffin and Brett Gurewitz about (recording) their album Stranger Than Fiction. It was done about 3 months before Brett decided to not tour with Bad Religion anymore.
Collection
Transcript
Original (English) · 6,711 words
Mr. Brett's Epitaph
It didn't seem like such a big deal to interview Bad Religion singer GREG GRAFFIN and guitarist MR. BRETT GUREWITZ, the two songwriters in the band, for Alternative Press on May 9, 1994---after all, I had interviewed Bad Religion twice before---but later events cast a different light on this discussion, which took place in Burbank's Encore studio while the band completed overdubs just prior to mixing their new album Stranger Than Fiction. The eighth album by Bad Religion would be their first original release on Atlantic Records; unwilling to wait for a new LP, the label had already reissued their previous album Recipe for Hate, which was originally released on Epitaph Records, the independent label run by Mr. Brett. Breaking two more band traditions, Bad Religion did not use the Westbeach studio owned by Mr. Brett, nor did they produce their own record.
Nevermind ond Dirty mixer ANDY WALLACE produced the album in seven weeks at two LA. studios: Rumbo, owned by THE CAPTAIN AND TENILLE---Bad Religion actually met the Captain himself during the sessions---and Encore.
Three months later Brett announced he would not be touring with Bad Religion this year; instead, equally famous punk guilarist BRIAN BAKER (formerly of MINOR THREAT, GOVERNMENT ISSUE, DAG NASTY, and JUNKYARD) would join the band for their upcoming world tour. Greg Graffin explained at the time, "Bad Religion wants to tour a lot for our brand new LP; the entire cycle will take about eight months. Brett is now unable to get off for that amount of time, due to the tumultuous time at Epitaph, what with THE OFFSPRING suddenly selling two million and the back catalog selling so well, including our older albums. He's got to be, less of an aclive member and more of an active label head. It's ironic that the year I took off from teaching to devote time to touring with the band has become the same year that Epitaph demanded so much more of Brett's time." Baker had reportedly been offered PETER HOLSAPPLE's slot as fifth member of the upcoming R.E.M. tour, but chose to join Bad Religion instead. By November, band members were admitting this was just damage control, and that Brett had in fact officially quit and Baker is a permanent member; although Brett left open the possibility of doing some future writing for the band (it's unclear whether such a contribution would be welcomed).
Brett had seemed less happy for the past year. He seemed to smile less, laugh less, and though just as sharp mentally, he was less talkative and enthusiastic. Bits of this shine through below. Other band members have denied that Brett was strongly opposed to the decision to sign a deal with Atlantic, but there was valid concern that the departure of Epitaph's biggest selling act might hurt the label. More likely, the tension increasingly visible in Brett over the past year was the result of overwork as Epitaph began to absorb more and more of his time, as he fought to maintain the prominence and reputation of his label after the ironic departure of his own band. More tellingly, Brett later told Alternative Press that he'd began to "grow apart from certain members of the band." Perhaps bits of this are visible below as well.
We're sorry that this turned out to be the last interview we conduct with Brett as a member of Bad Religion, the healthy sales of The Oltspring and Rykodisc's new SUGAR LP represent the biggest explosion of sales by indie post-punk records ever, an event that can only breathe much-needed life into the ailing indie distribution network. So long Brett, we will miss you. That said, as demonstrated resoundingly on their November tour, Bad Religion remains a powerhouse: America's most exciting, vital band, a national treasure which looks like it finally may be on the verge of breaking through to the masses.
For a complete discography prior to what you see here, we refer you to our earlier interviews with Bad Religion, the first published in The Big Takeover issues 28 and 29, the second in issues 32 and 33. Those interviews are also a better overview of the band's long history; this interview is focused entirely on the present. My thanks to JANE BOETTCHER and her husband COREY for the transcription.
---Jack Rabid
JR: Where did you track down WAYNE KRAMER?
GREG: That was Brett's idea and his experience.
BRETT: I signed Wayne Kramer to do a record for Epitaph and it just occurred to invite him to do a guest solo on the new LP.
JR: How did you come across him?
BRETT: He called me.
JR: Really?
BRETT: Yeah. He said he's got these great new songs and everyone who spoke to him pointed him towards Epitaph. He called me and said, "This is Wayne from MC5. Want to do a record?" And I said yes.
JR: Wow. Didn't you even have to hear his songs first?
BRETT: I said yes before I heard the songs. But obviously we went through all the formalities of getting a demo recorded. He always has been a great guitar player and he still is.
JR: How familiar are you with his post-MC5 work?
BRETT: I'm completely unfamiliar. However, I know he did a solo record. Regardless, the new record is going to be real great, because he's collaborating with a lot of young, contemporary artists who are Wayne Kramer fans, who are putting it together as a project. I think we'll really surprise people.
JR: Including a couple Bad Religion members, too, right?
BRETT: No, that's up to them. I don't know. But I know some guys from CLAWHAMMER and they will likely be on it. It's too early to say, but there should be a lot of cool players.
JR: And he plays on your new album.
BRETT: He plays on "lncomplete," he does a guitar solo.
JR: What other guest stars appear on this record?
GREG: I don't think there are any others...oh no, LINT [TIM ARMSTRONG] from RANCID sang part of Brett's song called "Television."
JR: No lap steel this album?
GREG: No.
JR: Too bad. I thought "Man On a Mission" from Recipe For Hate was terrific.
GREG: Yeah, there was nothing appropriate this time.
JR: How do you go about differentiating one album from the last? Do you even give it a thought?
GREG: What? In the writing process or in retrospect?
JR: Both the writing process and the recording process. No, I mean every time you have a new album to do, particularly when you have a bigger catalog, you get more to a point where your thoughts turn to "How do I not repeat myself?"
GREG: Yeah, definitely. Personally, I look at it from the perspective of where we are at the moment, and how our position at the moment has changed from the year before, or the cycle before, because a band's popularity and image is always changing. And hopefully, if you are a successful band it will always be increasing in popularity. So you have to consider with each new slice of time, "How do I want to appeal to those fans who have been with us for so long, and also have something new and fresh in there that has the potential to be heard by other people who haven't heard of us yet?"
JR: So, you're conscious of trying to broaden your audience?
GREG: Yeah I am.
BRETT: I'm not. My main goal...for me, writing a song is like pulling a rabbit out of a hat. I never know if I'm going to be able to write another decent song. I always hope I'll be able to, but I'm always surprised when I'm able to write one more, I set really short-term goals for myself. I just try to write one more song. When I start to record a new record, which is immediately after finishing the last record l'll probably start writing for the new record in a month or something---but really all I do is maybe I'll have an overall feeling for what I think the spirit of the record should be. Beyond that I just try to write a song I haven't written ever before and if I do that each time, hopefully, the record itself isn't a repeat.
JR: Have you gotten much criticism from people who say your records all sound alike?
BRETT: Not lately. We used to. The hardcore punk fans are sometimes fanatical. You know, first they complain, "All your songs sound the same," Then we released records like Generator and Recipe tor Hate so they started complaining that we changed, (Jack laughs) What I've decided is that it's better not to worry about it that much and just come up with an idea of what I want the spirit of the record to be, at least the spirit of the songs that I'm going to write this year, and then try to write the best songs possible, one at a time.
JR: So you really don't take into account at all the idea that this record you're working is in any way separate frorn what you've done in the past?
BRETT: No. No, I haven't. In fact, one thing I've tried to do is deliberately set out and tried to write a real hard, raw type of record. Well, like I said, I don't write records, I only write songs, and I can only write one at a time, but I tried really hard to write punk rock songs this year. I think there's a lot of question out there with our loyal fans as to whether we're going to change our musical style to try to appeal to, say, the KROQ audience or the PEARL JAM fan, you know what I mean, since we're now on a major label. I wanted to let them know that here's a record that our loyal fans can stand behind because it's punk as hell.
JR: Well, you more or less indirectly answered the question I really wanted to ask, but I thought it would be better if you said it instead of my asking. lt would be too easy to ask, "So, this is your first major label album. What's the pressure on you?"
BRETT: Well, there is pressure, but I feel real strongly that we should make a Bad Religion record.
GREG: Nothing Brett said has really contradicted what I said, We both agree that we feel loyalty to our early ians and we both agree that we want to make songs that sound like Bad Religion. As for my original answer about trying to write songs that can appeal to other people, it doesn't mean sacrificing the Bad Religion sound at all. lt just means taking what we've done in the past as a template and expanding on it.
JR: In fact, I actually thought Recipe For Hate was the biggest change from your previous work that you've ever made---at least it had the most new wrinkles, so to speak.
GREG: Maybe, yeah.
JR: And yet that was still an Epitaph production.
GREG: Yeah, and our punk following certainly didn't dislike it. It got us a lot of new fans, and who are we to say whether they're punk or not? That's their own personal philosophy.
JR: Well, in 1994 isn't that distinction sort of moot, anyway?
GREG: I'd probably get two diffrrent answers. I think that it definitely is.
JR: I'm hearing everybody called "punk" from the most committed hardcore, skinhead band to something definitely '70s lite-metal-rock Iike SOUNDGARDEN.
BRETT: Yeah, exactly.
JR: What is and isn't punk, it doesn't seem like anybody knows anymore. (pause) The word has become more abused than even two decades ago. Although, I think I know.
BRETT: Yeah, it's a spirit; you can tell if the music is or not.
JR: So, anyway, I guess you shouldn't even bother worrying about it.
GREG: Exactly. If you are "it" then why should you worry about it?
JR: I admit I've only heard seven songs from Stranger Than Fiction, but it almost seemed to me that some of the record is more of a return to what you were doing on Against the Grain and, to a Iesser extent, No Control.
GREG: Yeah. I think, like Brett said, I was in the same writing vein this year as he was, in trying to make songs that were truer to our heritage.
BRETT: Well, there are songs like that on our record, but there are also songs that kind of stretch the definition of what Bad Religion is. I'm not sure how many songs you heard, or which ones you heard. But there are definitely some that are risks for us.
JR: And which ones are those?
BRETT: I would say "Slumber" and "Infected" and possibly "Stranger Than Fiction" is a style of song that we haven't really done.
JR: (incredulous) You don't think "Stranger Than Fiction" is vaguely reminiscent of "Atomic Garden" (the single and video off 1992's Generator)? Even after only hearing it once, ten minutes ago...
BRETT: Well, it is basically reminiscent, but, yeah, vaguely reminiscent, I'll hand you that. But I would also say that the SEX PISTOLS are vaguely reminiscent of CHUCK BERRY, too. (all laugh)
JR: What, for you, are the newest wrinkles on the record? Where do you hear something that makes you think, "Man, there's something really nice and new for us---omething really fresh?" I didn't hear anything like that just now.
BRETT: I just told you,
JR: Well, be more specific, now that we've got the songs.
BRETT: Say what?
JR: In what way are they fresher and newer? I've got the titles now, but describe them more.
BRETT: I think "Stranger Than Fiction" is probably the best pop song I've ever written. It's kind of a tribute to groups like the CLASH and the JAM and ELVIS COSTELLO, although it doesn't necessarily sound like any one of them. It's a little more high energy the way we do it. It retains its punk rock edge but at the same time it's pure pop. It's kind of like, yeah, you mentioned Generator. It's where I was trying to go with a song like "Atomic Garden." It's probably a more fully realized concept of where I was going with that song. Even a song like "Hooray For Me (And Fuck You)"---did you hear that one?
JR: No, not yet.
BRETT: It's one of my favorite ones that I wrote. Bad Religion has never really done a song like it before. Let's see, what about it is fresh?
JR: Is it the rhythm?
BRETT: No, it's a fast tempo; it's a tempo that you'll recognize.
JR: I didn't say anything about the tempo. I meant the actual bass and drums.
BRETT: Yeah, it is different. Actually, it's one that we haven't used before. It's one that NOFX and PENNYWISE use more often than us. (laughs) No, the song itself, the chord changes and the song structure and some of the guitar tones have the spirit of '77 punk rock with a real '50s roots-rock infusion, but at the same time it's hardcore, Bad Religion-type punk. I wish you could have heard it; I'm really happy with how it came out.
JR: I don't want to take up all your expensive studio time playing the LP for me when you could be recording instead. But for instance, on the last record, when I heard that lap steel not just because there was lap steel on a Bad Religion record, but because it worked so well, it created a mood and a style I'd never heard from your band before, and the song became my favorite on the LP. It had such a sad, forlorn edge to it...
BRETT: Yes, it's definitely a sound you've never heard on a Bad Religion record before. Maybe it wouldn't be as striking.
GREG: Yeah, it wouldn't be as obvious to most people.
BRETT: We did more experimenting with guitar sounds on this record than we ever have. And I love a lot of the sounds. I love all the sounds, Each song has its own guitar tone, although all of them are really raw and explosive. I'm such a fan of guitar. I love the electric guitar---the sound and timbre of electric guitar---so much, and it's really been great to experiment.
JR: Have you been using a lot of equipment that you didn't have before?
BRETT: Yeah.
JR: What have you added to your arsenal?
BRETT: I got myself a '73 Marshall head without a master volume. Which is great because I was talking to Wayne Kramer about it, and it's the same style of Marshall he used in the MC5. And when he did a solo, he used a Strat through that Marshall. It's such a great sound because it doesn't have a master volume, so you can't get that kind of modern-sounding distortion. You just have to turn it up as loud as it will go, so it gets on the verge of where it sounds like it's going to blow up. And that's how you get your distortion. I used a lot of that this year. I used this old '65 Strat I have through a vintage fuzz box called a Fuzz Face for some songs. I used an amplifier called a Matchless which has kind of the sound of a Vox AC30 amplifier---I used that on some songs. I used a '59 Les Paul reissue on a lot of stuff. We just mixed and matched a real dominance of cool guitar sounds.
JR: I thought I heard a fuzz bass on one of the tracks, too.
BRETT: Yeah, that wasn't a fuzz bass though. That was that bass with an old tube amp cranked. We got more of an authentic distortion.
JR: Which track was that again?
BRETT: "Incomplete." That's the one Wayne played on.
JR: No, I didn't hear that one.
GREG: You heard in the middle of "The Handshake."
JR: That was it. What about lyrically? Is there anything lyrically on this record to distinguish it from your past work?
GREG: I think they're the best lyrics I've ever written, but I've spent more time writing this record. I spent more time on these songs than in the past. Maybe it's because this is the first year I took time off from teaching, and I had more time to be creative. So I'm really proud of a lot of my writing on this.
JR: What songs are you most proud of?
GREG: I think "lndividual" is one of my better songs, lyrically.
JR: That chorus on "Tiny Voices" is sort of a philosophical treatise. Was that inspired by anything in particular? I caught the words, "And if you don't confront them they will never go away."
GREG: Yeah, that song was actually going to be written about the problems in Bosnia, but it evolved into a much broader topic, lt's really a song about dead people and innocent deaths that have occrured because of our negligence. The whole metaphor of "tiny voices" is one of conscience. The song talks about the actual voices of the dead people who we've overlooked, coming and haunting us in our sleep.
JR: I actually came up with a different interpretation---that people who ignore their own inner voices as to what they really want to do, do so at their own peril---you know, no one can delude you like yourself.
GREG: At their own peril, though?
JR: You know, if you think that something will make you happy and you do it, and it doesn't make you happy, now you're worse off, because you're disillusioned and mad at yourself.
GREG: You're screwed because you've committed yourself.
JR: You've tricked yourself into thinking that something you wanted would make you happy if you got it, when deep down inside you always knew it wouldn't.
GREG: Right. And by ignoring all the atrocities, we are fooling ourselves into thinking we can live insular, happy lives.
JR: What about you, Brett?
BRETT: My lyrics are different this year, although I'm trying to think of what my lyrics were like last year. I guess they're about the same, but I think they're better. I wrote twice as many songs this year as I did last year. I wrote eight this year, whereas I only wrote four last year. I think my lyrics have improved. I don't know if any one song is the best song I've written yet.
JR: Did you have anything in particular you wanted to get off your chest? I know, for example, the songs about the Gulf War that each of you wrote on the Maximum Rock and Roll single that later appeared on Generator ("Heaven is Falling" and "Fertile Crescent") were particular tour de forces where one could feel that you two really felt enormously strongly about saying something.
BRETT: Yeah, I think you can sense some strong emotions in the songs. It's hard to comment on.
JR: Harder still for me to ask, since I haven't actually heard most of the new ones, and what I've heard has been one take through.
GREG: It's ironic that "Slumber" is a song about suicide, though
JR: Since I believe you just made a NIRVANA reference, I take it to mean "Slumber" was written before...KURT COBAIN is not the first person to kill himself, obviously.
GREG: But we were thinking of calling the record We loveYou, Kurt.
JR: (laughs) But somehow that didn't get past the committee, eh?
GREG: (laughs) Just kidding.
JR: Have you always had this much difIiculty naming your albums?
GREG: Oh, they always come down to the wire, yeah. Sometimes a concept is a little easier to envision as a title. Last year, when Recipe For Hate was in its early stages, I was pretty confident that it would be a good title, but it doesn't sit well with,..you know, we all have to come to some sort of an agreement and eventually it was decided upon. Early on, How Could Hell Be Any Worse was an easy title because we were all into the concept.
JR: And the photo that went with it was pretty ironic (an aerial view of Hollywood drenched in crimson, as if it were engulfed in Hell's flames--the back cover had an illustration of the descent into hell from Dante's Inferno).
GREG: We actually commissioned the photo. We said, "Let's get a photo of Hollywood and call it How Could Hell Be Any Worse."
JR: It would have been even funnier if you had signed to Capitol instead of Atlantic (the unigue Capitol building is the centerpiece of that 1982 LP cover photo).
GREG: I know. That'd be excellent.
JR: I was interested to learn that you don't seem to have many band meetings. Is that a function of geography or are you just not a very forrnal group?
GREG: I think we're not that formal. I mean, we can do it on the phone by conference. The band doesn't really have to decide that many things as an entity.
JR: Isn't everything about in being a band, though, a sort of process of different choices that have to be made?
GREG: Yeah, but when you decide to tour, you all know you're going to be touring, so we don't all get together to decide which cities to go to---that's why you hire a booking agent.
JR: Well, no, I mean a lot of the other little day-to-day things. The sort that lead groups with tension in them to bicker constantly about seemingly minor issues.
GREG: We have a manager, of course, who can do that.
JR: No, I mean the things that can only be decided by the musicians.
GREG: Like what songs to play?
JR: Like "Joe wants to play this song tonight and Ron wants to play that song..." Or "Sally doesn't like the lyrics you wrote" or "Steve hates the photo you want to use for the press file..."
GREG: Exsuse me, what band are you interviewing? (laughs) Joe, Bill, and who? (all laugh) I know. Yeah, but those kind of things... you know, just like any family there are certain members who insist on things more than others. If everyone was insistent, we would have to have a meeting every hour to come up with decisions, or a meeting every day to decide things. I try to be pretty easygoing on decisions about what songs we play and stuff like that. I think it helps things go smoothly. We have an ultimate goal in mind, and that is to get the concert done, right?
JR: In the past---the fairly distant past, mind you---I've heard both of you refer to the group as a part-time affair, a four-month-out-of-twelve band, or something. Have those days ended now?
GREG: Well, the spirit is still there, because I don't ever want to think of myself as a... (pause) ...full-time "anything," I think about this a lot, obviously, because you want to be able to characterize yourself. You want to think of yourself as something. I want to think of myself as someone who is creative. I choose academia and music to be my two theaters of creativity, but I don't want to get stuck in any one theater. I'm always open-minded about trying other avenues creativity.
JR: Well, that's not to say that full-time bands can't have other hobbies or interests or occupations. For instance, you said that you took a year off from teaching to do this album and tour. Was that incidental or was that band-related?
GREG: No, that was band-related, definitely.
JR: How long can you continue that, for example?
GREG: A couple more years, maybe, because I can still get (paleontological) research done. That's the thing; if you're not teaching, you're able to do more research.
JR: It's a formal sabbatical from Cornell, then?
GREG: Yeah. It's not even considered a sabbatical as such, because sabbaticals---you really are supposed to be spending the full amount of time on research. Everyone who works with me there knows I'm not doing that. (laughs)
JR: You're just gathering those punk rock fossils. (all laugh)
GREG: Exactly, they're not going to fall for that. (Jack and Greg laugh) I've increased my time with the band, definitely, but on the other hand, I think it's still good for people to know we still have our other interests.
JR: Has signing a major label deal forced your hand in this?
GREG: Absolutely not. I want to make very clear that the decision was made before we ever signed to Atlantic. I knew I was going to take this year off. It was more of a decision that we made for touring reasons on Recipe For Hate while we were still an Epitaph band.
JR: What made Recipe For Hate different from other albums in that respect?
GREG: I don't know. There just comes a time when you make a decision like that---like, "We're going to put a little more significant touring into this record."
JR: More than just summers and other school holidays?
GREG: Yeah. I wouldn't put too much significance on which album it occurred with. It is significant that it occured before a major label deal, though. We could have done it with the record before that, with Generator, but for whatever reason, we didn't.
JR: What about you, Brett? How has your commitment to the band or your attitude about it been influenced by recent events.
BRETT: It's been Pretty tough on me, because I still work every second on Epitaph when I'm not playing in the band. I'm pretty run-down right now.
JR: Are you wearing too many hats?
BRETT: No, I can handle the hats. I'm just working too much. I need to find a balance or just cut my load down.
JR: Is a recording project a major intrusion on your business and social lilfe. ..or I should say, your home life?
BRETT: (with indicative weariness) I don't have a social life or a home life, I haven't for the last few months.
GREG: It's a major intrusion on mine as well. It would have been nice if we recorded in Ithaca, but my wife GRETA was able to come out of here for part of it, so that was good. I've been here for six weeks, and whenever you go away from home for six weeks, no matter what, it's a major intrusion.
JR: I don't suppose it's any better even though you're in one place rather than on tour, traveling every day?
GREG: No, it's not. It's like, I'm as comfortable now as I am on tour everyday.
JR: The fact that you don't have to drive six hours a day makes no difference?
GREG: But even so, you're living in hotels, and you're working every day, so it's pretty much the same.
JR: Your big buddies in the band won't put you up for a while?
GREG: Oh yeah, they would, of course.
JR: You'd rather have your own place?
GREG: It's nice to see them during the day and then go away at night.
JR: Is this album taking longer than your previous ones?
GREG: Yes.
JR: Is that because you've hired an outside person to produce? Or is it just that you wanted to make a more carelful record?
GREG: I think it's a lot to do with having an added important creative element in the band, that being the producer.
JR: What's the longest you ever spent making an album in the past?
GREG: Recipe For Hate took probably four weeks, maybe five weeks, but it was back and forth. See, I came out, reecorded it, and mixed part of it in three weeks, Then I went home and about a month later we started to dally with---we had a lot of time before the release date---so we started to remix some of the songs. By the time we were done with that we remixed the whole record. So, that's why it took so much more time. That really was slated to be done in three-and-a-half or four weeks.
JR: Well, you can do that if you're not working on somebody else's schedule, right?
GREG: Part of it is that, and I'm not saying that it's a bad thing, but just having another person involved takes more time. You've got to incorporate ideas, do things in a different systematic way, and it's a new protocol.
JR: Is it bizarre surrendering that element of complete control?
GREG: Not when you respect the work that the guy you're working with has done.
JR: Nevertheless, I'm sure he proposes things that seem alien to you.
BRETT: It hasn't been totally comfortable for me, but then again, I was also the recording engineer on past projects. So, it's even more of a drastic turnaround for me.
JR: Do you have to fight the impulse to constantly get at the knobs yourself?
BRETT: No.
GREG: Let's make one thing clear, though. ANDY WALLACE is very diplomatic, and he's not down there insisting on anything. He really wants to capture what the band sounds like. That's his goal.
JR: I didn't hear one minute of the recording that sounded to me like you couldn't have done it yourself, though.
GREG: I don't know about that.
JR: I didn't hear the iron will of a producer imposed upon a band.
GREG: Right, it's not like that at all.
JR: What was the decision process involved in selecting him? Did you consciously come to a decision that you wanted to make a record that wasn't done entirely by yourselves?
GREG: I think so. I wasn't that involved in it. I would have done it either way.
JR: (to Brett) And you? Do you recall how this came about?
BRETT: No, I don't remember exactly. I remember wanting, this year, to have a record that sounded better than any of our other records---not meaning refined or cleaner but just sounding better. I don't think we've ever fully realized our sound---most likely because of my own shortcomings as a recording engineer---so I was in favor of working with a producer. I'm not sure exactly how we ended up with Andy, except that he had expressed interest in working with us, and I'm a fan of some of his productions.
JR: Specifically?
BRETT: Well, he may not have produced Nevermind but he mixed it and I think it sounds great. The SLAYER records he did sound great. I'm not a real big metal fan but those are some of the coolest sounding records. I love the way SONIC YOUTH's Drirty sounded; he mixed that. He also did a remix that probably no one has ever heard, because it never really saw the light of day. He did a remix for us on Recipe For Hate's "American Jesus," and I like the way it sounded.
JR: I'm surprised, even so, that you're not working out of Westbeach if for no other reason than all the money you'd save.
GREG: Yes, but Andy requires a certain type of board that Westbeach doesn't have---an SSL---for mixing. For tracking, again, I stayed out of the decisions for tracking. I don't know why we didn't go there. Maybe because of the structure of the different rooms. Westbeach has one isolation booth.
JR: Maybe that question is better directed to Brett, then.
GREG: Yeah, I think we all wanted to play in the same room at the same time.
BRETT: I think what it came down to is that when you hire somebody to be your engineer, or when you hire a producer who works with an engineer, you don't tell them where you're going to record. You tell them what area you want to stay in if that's where you all Iive, but you pretty much let them choose the studio. It has to be someplace they're comfortable with. So when we hired him, we said, "Look, we'd Iike to do some recording in the L.A, area," and I let him know l had this studio and I described it to him, but there wasn't any pressure. We just said, "Pick your studio. This is roughly how much time we'd want to spend. This is roughly what we can afford. Other than that, it's up to you." You know, it's out of respect for him because he's making the record.
JR: Are you on schedule?
BRETT: Yeah.
JR: Yet you've been gone six weeks now, you said?
GREG: Actually, I flew out here six weeks ago, but we spent a week rehearsing. Hey, there's something different! (laughs)
JR: You never did that before?
GREG: No. We actually rehearsed for this. It was mostly because we wanted to track with all of us playing at the same time, and try to capture as much of that in the original, basic tracks as we could.
JR: So, this is like the first live Bad Religion studio album?
GREG: It's more live than usual.
JR: Is this the way you used to do it when you first started?
GREG: Uh-huh, yeah.
JR: And then after a while you got to tracking (recording backing tracks, before vocals are added) individually?
GREG: Yep.
JR: So, I had a discussion with Brett the last time I saw him which I will recall now if he doesn't mind. On something like Recipe For Hate's "Struck a Nerve," is it just my imagination, or did KROQ only start playing that when you signed a majror label deal? That's how the chronology appeared to me when that song finally broke, several months after it was released.
GREG: It's probably not your imagination.
GREG HETSON: I think they started playing it after we did their acoustic Christmas.
GREG: Yeah, that's when it really got full rotation. So, through the entire acroustic Christmas.
JR: When did you sign? In August or something like that?
GREG: Uh-huh. Yeah, it's an interesting observation, ack, but I don't know what your point is.
JR: Well, what made the song better six months later than when you first submitted it?
GREG: Nothing, but you know as well as I that what's played on the radio is not the best stuff. What gets played on the radio is stuff that gets promoted to radio.
JR: Well, I know what I have to say about it, but it's what you have to say about it that I'm looking for. I mean, do you feel like suddenly it took some stupid thing like this to legitimize the fact that you've been making good music all along?
GREG: No.
JR: In the hands of radio programmers and TV programmers?
GREG: That doesn't legitimize it.
JR: I don't mean in your eyes. I mean in terms of commercial access, commercial exposure.
GREG: No, and as a matter of fact, I never expected the success that "Struck a Nerve" had, I never thought it was going to be so well-played on stations like KROQ. So I think it would be wrong to base our decision to go to a major label on being popular on radio. That's not why.
JR: I'm sure that had no impact at all on your decision. It's more an observation I've made and I want to know how you react to it.
GREG: I'm not opposed to it. I want to take advantage of what the major label can offer us, but not at the expense of our credibility.
JR: I'll be even more specific about what sticks in my craw. When I was here in February, they were playing that song once every two or three hours, and they were saying, "That's local favorites Bad Religion!', you know, implying, "our boys." And I said to myself, "Wait a minute. I've been coming out here for twelve years listening to this station and I've never heard KROQ play Bad Religion. What is this, their first album?"
GREG: Well, they can claim a certain loyalty to us only because of one DJ, RODNEY BINGENHEIMER. So, is absurd as the people in the know think it is, it stil can't be denied that Rodney really gave us our first radio exposure, and KROQ can use that to their advantage.
JR: Okay. I was in Michigan a couple years ago and I heard a SOCIAL DISTORTION track on the radio---on an AOR station, not even a KROQ station, a classic rock station.
GREG: (sings) "Bad, Bad Luck"?
JR: It was either that, or the other one that got a certain amount of AOR crossover. The attitude in the DJ's voice was very much like, "yeah, this is a band that we play. They fit here. We've always liked them." Like "Of course, that's Social Distortion. Everybody likes them. Everybody knows them."
BRETT: If I can take the wind out of your sails, though?
JR: By all means.
BRETT: I think what you're describing is true, and it happens all the time, In fact, I know the kind oI slimy radio game intimately.
JR: Lay it on us.
BRETT: No, I'll just say it's true. That shit happens, no question. On the other hand, it's possible to have a spontaneous, organic radio hit on an indie label, because right now on Epitaph the OFFSPRING have a song called "Come Out and Play" which is getting forty spins a week on KROQ, which is more than "Struck a Nerve" ever got. (Note: This is just after it's release!! Little did any of us know.) And they're getting four million impressions at BDS, which is an electronic tracking system in radio. Last week...
JR: I heard them this morning, actually, on KROQ.
BRETT: It's a killer song, Epitaph is a small indie. We don't pander to any of the kind oI legal payola bullshit that goes on. WDRE is adding it. Q101 in Chicago,. It's a spontaneous streetlevel phenomenon and it's just exploded and it's real. So, it can happen, but in most cases when a song is on radio it's not real, it's created.
